NAFTA Talks: Emails Reveal Just How Carefully Liberals Orchestrated Canada's Message

OTTAWA — The Liberal government has been orchestrating the Canadian approach to the North American Free Trade Agreement talks so carefully that at one point, Ottawa issued talking points to help ensure even the provinces and territories were all speaking with one voice.

The email inbox of Steve Verheul, Canada’s chief NAFTA negotiator, shows the Global Affairs Canada had prepared message lines for other levels of government on the very day last summer that the U.S. first released goals for a new trilateral deal.

“Canada’s position is that any modernization of NAFTA will need to take the North American relationship forward,” said one of the proposed lines.

The Canadian Press obtained the emails in response to an access-to-information request.

The package included facts and figures on how the U.S. benefits from trade with Canada, but suggested little be said when asked about specific topics U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer put on his list.

The American summary released last July 17 included things like keeping “Buy America” rules, increasing the amount Canadians can purchase online without paying import duties and a greater ability to export U.S. agricultural goods, such dairy products, which in Canada are protected by supply management.

“The objectives are not outcomes,” was one of the suggested responses to questions about specific items on the list.

“Canada looks forward to sitting at the table with negotiators from Mexico and the U.S. to modernize the NAFTA,” was another.

The document also did not include any specifics on what Canada would like to see in the new agreement, beyond some vague language on modernizing digital trade and customs facilitation and noted the U.S. is required by law to publish its objectives.

Ottawa also expected the provinces and territories, whose premiers were gathering that week in Edmonton, to mention that modernizing the 1994 agreement with the U.S. and Mexico would give Canada the chance to push for what has become a key part of the Trudeau trade agenda.

“A strong, modern and flexible NAFTA is important for North America to maintain its competitiveness in an increasingly complex and connected global marketplace,” the document said. “The modernization of NAFTA also offers Canada the opportunity to integrate progressive, free and fair approaches to North American trade and investment.”

Grits pushing ‘progressive’ elements

The Liberal government has been working to incorporate such “progressive” elements into trade deals, which in the case of NAFTA included proposing entire chapters on gender equality and Indigenous rights.

Alex Lawrence, a spokesman for Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland, said in a statement that Ottawa is working closely with its partners.

“We continue to closely collaborate with our provincial and territorial partners, who have a key interest in NAFTA, which has provided 24 years of stability and prosperity to North America,” Lawrence said. “We will always defend and maintain the elements of NAFTA that are important to Canadians.”

Syrian Kurds request help from Assad regime after US abandons them

Kurdish Syrian forces have asked the Syrian government for protection against a Turkish attack in a flashpoint town, triggered by a shock US decision to withdraw forces from the country which left them exposed.

Syrian troops erected the national flag in the outskirts of Manbij – the first time it has flown in the northern town for more than six years.

“The aim is to ward off a Turkish offensive,” said Ilham Ahmed, a senior Kurdish official. “If the Turks’ excuse is the (Kurdish militia), they will leave their posts to the government.”

A statement released earlier by the Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG) said they had invited government forces to the town, as they are “obliged to protect the same country, nation and borders."

Kurdish YPG fighters still based there are part of the US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) alliance battling Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (Isil). The town has been governed for the last two years by the Manbij Military Council, which is allied to the SDF.

It is the first major concession by the Kurds to the Bashar al-Assad regime since the YPG seized control of vast swathes of north and east Syria and created an area of self-rule and one which analysts called a major turning point.

Until last week the YPG had the support of the US, which had helped them stave off a threatened offensive by Turkey and Turkish-backed Syrian rebels and hold territory wanted by the Syrian regime.

A number of Syrian troops arrived in the area early Friday morning and deployed between YPG and Turkish-backed forces west of Manbij. 

A Syrian army spokesman said in a televised statement that all Syrians must “join efforts to preserve national sovereignty” and “defeat all invaders”, with reference to Turkey.

The US-backed coalition had a number of special forces stationed in the city, where they have a base. It is understood they will withdraw in the next few days.

It is unclear of local residents will react to regime forces returning to the city.

"No one knows what to think as the regime has not yet arrived," one resident of Manbij, who declined to be named, told the Telegraph. "Anyone with any connection to the revolution will probably try to leave soon, maybe for areas controlled by Turkey in the Euphrates Shield."

The town of some 100,000 people fell to moderate rebel fighters in the summer of 2012 before it was overrun by Isil jihadists in 2014. It was then captured by SDF in an anti-Isil offensive in 2016.

The Kurds have used the cover of the war to carve out an autonomous state in northeastern Syria. However, their project seems increasingly under threat as Assad’s regime looks to reclaim the whole of Syria.

Kurdish officials have told The Telegraph they would rather try their luck in negotiations with the regime than risk an all-out assault from neighbouring Turkey, which considers the YPG a terrorist group and has watched Kurdish expansion with growing concern.

“The YPG accepts drinking the poison to stop a massacre. Do you prefer your people to be massacred by a brutal dictator like (Turkish president Recep Tayyip) Erdogan or be protected by a brutal dictator like Assad?” tweeted Kamal Chomani, a non-resident fellow at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy.

Russia, which has long called for the withdrawal of US troops “illegally” in Syria, welcomed the news on Friday, with Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov describing the development as a "positive step" that could help "stabilise the situation."

Speaking in frank terms on Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw 2,000 troops from Syria, Jeremy Hunt, Foreign Secretary, today said the US president “makes a speciality of talking in very black and white terms about what’s happening in the world.”

"We have made massive progress in the war against Daesh (Arabic acronym for Isil), but it’s not over and, although they have lost nearly all the territory they held, they still hold some territory and there is still some real risk," Mr Hunt told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.

During a visit to Iraq this week, Mr Trump declared an end to the US role of being the world’s "policeman".

Arab leaders have in recent days taken steps to rehabilitate the brutal Assad regime, with the UAE and Bahrain announcing they are to reopen embassies that had been shut since the beginning of the civil war.

Tear gas fired as anti-migration protesters clash with police outside EU in Brussels

Belgian riot police used tear gas and water cannon on Sunday to disperse thousands of people protesting in Brussels against a UN migration pact.

Demonstrators held aloft banners bearing slogans including "Our people first" and "We have had enough, close the borders."

The protest outside the European Union headquarters in Brussels was organised by Flemish Right-wing parties and had initially been banned, but the ban was overturned this weekend by Belgium’s high court, which cited the right to protest. 

A minority of the estimated 5,500 demonstrators became violent when they were asked to disperse and began throwing paving stones, street furniture and and firecrackers at security forces near the European Commission building.

Police responded with tear gas and water cannon.

A counter-demonstration of around 1,000 people took place peacefully in the centre of the Belgian capital, organised by Left-wing groups and non-governmental organisations in favour of the non-binding UN migration pact.

The Right-wing New Flemish Alliance (N-VA), the biggest party in parliament, pulled its ministers from the ruling coalition last week after Charles Michel, the prime minister, refused its demand that he not sign the UN migration compact in Marrakesh.

That leaves Mr Michel, who belongs to the liberal Mouvement Reformateur party, at the helm of a minority government with five months to go before legislative elections.

The UN pact aims at creating a global approach to migration and was initially supported by all four parties in Belgium’s coalition. 

But the N-VA reversed its position in October and later voted against it, along with the far-Right Vlaams Belang party.

Marine Le Pen, leader of France’s far-Right National Rally, and Steve Bannon, a former advisor to US president Donald Trump, denounced the UN pact at an event in Brussels last weekend.

“The country that signs the pact obviously signs a pact with the devil,” Ms Le Pen said.

The UN pact was agreed in July by all 193 UN members except the US, but only 164 formally signed it at a meeting last Monday in Morocco.

Critics say the deal could increase immigration to Europe.

Ten countries, mostly in formerly Communist Eastern Europe, have pulled out of the pact.

With a record 21.3 million refugees globally, the UN began work on the pact after more than one million people arrived in Europe in 2015, many fleeing civil war in Syria and poverty in Africa.

Pope Francis on Sunday voiced his support for the agreement and urged the international community to show "responsibility, solidarity and compassion" in dealing with migrants. 

Francis stressed the pact was designed to secure "safe, ordered and regular migration." 

The deal is expected to be ratified at UN headquarters in New York on December 19.

Triangle, Canadian Tire's Revamped Loyalty Program, Expanded To Other Stores

TORONTO — Canadian Tire Corp. says it’s expanding its loyalty program to allow customers to collect and redeem Canadian Tire Money across its various retail brands.

The company says starting later this spring, customers will be able to collect points at Sport Chek, Mark’s, Atmosphere and Gas+ locations in addition to Canadian Tire itself, as well as redeem them at locations other than Gas+ stations.

Canadian Tire says the revamped program will be called Triangle and include both loyalty points and two new MasterCards issued under the program.

The program will allow customers to collect points either through an app or a loyalty card that will also offer personalized content and offers, while purchases with the branded MasterCards earn additional points.

Right time to update: Chief marketing officer

The update to the loyalty program comes amid wider shifts in loyalty programs in Canada, including Air Canada moving away from Aimia Inc.’s Aeroplan program to its own system, and Loblaw Co. combining loyalty programs at its grocery stores and Shoppers Drug Mart, as companies look to better target customers.

Canadian Tire Corp. chief marketing officer Susan O’Brien said the time was right to update the loyalty program that’s been active since 1958 as competition increases.

“We’ve got wonderful competition out there that’s making us think through new ways to connect our customers better and give them back the value that they want,” said O’Brien.

“We have a ton of analytics and data that helps us make decisions of course, and one of the things we know is a customer shops at Mark’s, shops at Canadian Tire retail, shops at Sport Chek, so why wouldn’t we be giving them the benefit and the rewards that go along with it?”

Also On HuffPost:

Warning of ‘genocide’ as Amazon tribes face being wiped out by Brazil’s new hard-Right president

Indigenous rights groups have warned they are rapidly running out of time to save one of the world’s most vulnerable Amazonian tribes before far-Right Brazilian president-elect Jair Bolsonaro is sworn into office on 1 January.

Human rights organisation Survival International is lobbying the Brazilian government to map out and protect the land of the uncontacted Kawahiva tribe.

The Kawahiva are hunter-gatherers based in the territory of Rio Pardo, in Brazil’s southern Amazonian region. The Brazilian indigenous affairs agency, FUNAI, estimates that there are over 100 such isolated tribes across the country.

Survival also demands increased policing in and around the tribal territory, to avoid what…

CDU party members quit in protest at Merkel successor as split widens in Germany’s ruling party

Local members of Germany’s ruling Christian Democrats have quit in protest at Angela Merkel’s chosen successor winning the race to lead the party.

Just a day after the CDU appeared to end weeks of infighting by voting in Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, known as "mini Merkel", delegates at the party’s congress told The Sunday Telegraph of a wave of resignations among rank and file members.

Victory for Ms Kramp-Karrenbauer is seen by many as a failure of the party to learn from the mistakes of Mrs Merkel, and a missed opportunity to regain ground on the Right on key issues such as immigration.

Party delegates from several regions of Germany confirmed that members left the CDU after Ms Kramp-Karrenbauer defeated pro-business figure Frierdich Merz by a mere 35 of the 999 delegate votes on Friday. One prominent party figure confirmed that “very many” of the party rank and file had quit.

The contest, which sets the stage for the CDU to maintain its moderate edge after Mrs Merkel steps down in 2021, laid bare divisions that have been simmering inside the CDU over Ms Merkel’s refugee policies and her perceived anti-business instincts.

In her victory speech on Friday, Ms Kramp-Karrenbauer – often referred to simply as AKK – stressed that the party now needed to come together.

But many delegates at the conference were left deflated by what they see as a vote for the continuation of policies that have lost the party millions of voters to the populist AfD and the Greens in recent months.

Ms Kramp-Karrenbauer was tapped by Ms Merkel to take over the powerful role of party general-secretary in February, a move widely interpreted as positioning her to become Chancellor.

During campaigning the 56-year-old made it her mission to convince people she wasn’t the mini-Merkel, as the German press have labelled her. Nonetheless Mr Merz, who hasn’t been in frontline politics for over a decade, represented the clearest break with the Merkel era. He repeatedly harangued the party hierarchy for failing to stop the rise of the AfD.

“The CDU had a chance to change its course and it didn’t take it,” Urban Lanig, a delegate from southern state of Baden-Württemberg, said on Saturday. Seven people have left his local party chapter in the past 24 hours, he said.

Describing AKK’s policy positions as “a cheap imitation of the Social Democrats,” Mr Urban said the CDU would continue its tailspin in popularity under its new leader.

Carsten Linnemann, head of the powerful CDU trade association, told The Sunday Telegraph that “many people are very disappointed and it’s going to take time for them to get over it. Ms Kramp-Karrenbauer needs to now set her own tone and give the party a clear profile that distinguishes it from the opposition.”

Others talked down the significance of the resignations.

“There have been threats of resignations in our local chapter, but I wouldn’t take it too seriously,” a delegate from the north said. “These things happen when you have a new party leader.”

Four days before launch, Red Dead Redemption 2 suffers its first gameplay leak

UPDATE 2 – 24th Oct 2018: Rockstar is working to take down Red Dead Redemption 2 video leaks on YouTube.

A raft of videos that emerged today, including the one Eurogamer reported on this morning, are now unavailable on YouTube.

UPDATE 1 – 24th Oct 2018: Red Dead Redemption 2 has suffered another leak – this time apparently from Russia.

The video below is four minutes and 40 seconds of gameplay footage of Rockstar’s cowboy game, showing Arthur Morgan shooting and punching a whole load of people in a town. Of note: the footage shows the game’s first-person mode.

The quality of the video is poor (it looks like it was a stream filmed using a potato!), but it gives us the longest stretch of uncut gameplay footage seen to date.

Red Dead Redemption 2 comes out on 26th October, so the game will be in plenty of people’s hands already. Expect more leaks in the coming days.

ORIGINAL STORY 22nd Oct 2018: Four days before Red Dead Redemption 2 is due to launch officially, its first gameplay leak has hit the internet.

A 23-second clip of Rockstar’s epic is currently online now, although I suspect it won’t be long for this world (thanks, reddit).

The clip, which isn’t particularly illuminating, shows playable character Arthur Morgan rock up to a campsite, pat his horse, get down then blow a few bad guys away.

There’s a lot here fans of Red Dead Redemption will recognise, including the mini-map, the wanted system and the radial menu for weapons.

New is the slow motion kill cam, horse items and Premium Cigarette Packs, which you can obtain for a collectible cigarette card.

Of note: there are icons around the mini-map, and you can press L2 to “Lawman”.

This short clip is the first gameplay leak Red Dead Redemption 2 has suffered, which comes as something of a surprise given how close we are to the launch of the game and the fact copies of it are already in the hands of players.

Not long now!

  • Read Eurogamer’s Red Dead Redemption 2 review

Toronto Van Attack, Rising Security Concerns Leave Car Rental Agencies Struggling With Screenings

Monday’s deadly rental van rampage in Toronto shows how quickly a vehicle can be turned into a weapon, but rental agencies are finding few clear options to prevent their property from involvement in such violent acts.

The urgency to find solutions is increasing, however.

The attack in Toronto that left at least 10 people dead and several injured is only the latest of a spate of vehicle attacks — including one in Edmonton last September — that have security experts grappling with solutions.

Efforts are further along in Europe, which has seen a rash of vehicle attacks across the continent. In the U.K., vehicle rental companies were asked to conduct tougher background checks following two separate van attacks in London last June.

‘Like any normal person’

But rental agencies are still limited in how well they can screen customers, said Toby Poston, director of communications at the British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association.

“Members aren’t experts at profiling customers,” said Poston.

“People don’t come into rental branches wearing camo gear and stab vests and with that sort of glint in their eye. Quite often, these people just present themselves like any normal person.”

The British association is, however, looking to better co-ordinate with law and security officials to make it easier to share data. Poston said rental agencies wouldn’t have access to terror watchlists or the like, but could potentially feed information to authorities for better monitoring.

Member companies are also looking to potentially institute other record searches like credit and criminal background checks, but even then there is no clear way to determine that a vehicle shouldn’t be rented, said Poston.

“You have to remember that a criminal record is not always reason enough to not rent someone a vehicle. And you have to be careful from a discrimination point of view.”

The accused in the Toronto van attack, Alek Minassian, did not even raise any red flags during a brief stint in the Canadian Armed Forces last year, a military source told The Canadian Press.

Toronto police said he rented the van from a Ryder rental location north of the city. The company said Tuesday it was fully co-operating with authorities, but declined to comment on its current security policies.

The Associated Canadian Car Rental Operators said government officials have yet to reach out to try to co-ordinate data sharing.

But any such efforts would be complicated, said vice president of government relations Craig Hirota.

“It’s challenging, how do you use that information so that it doesn’t infringe on existing rights of the individual and rights to privacy?”

The RCMP’s National Critical Infrastructure Team has been in contact with industry and sends out relevant information, Hirota added.

“We are in the loop with local and federal law enforcement when there are bulletins.”

He said the rental industry has long been concerned with fraudulent and criminal activity with rentals, but there are limited options for screenings.

“Vehicle rental agencies have been concerned with people doing bad things with rental cars since the inception of the industry. Obviously if there was a way to tell a renter was going to do something prohibited with your vehicle, we’d love to have that.”

European countries implementing new measures

The U.K. rental association is looking to security models elsewhere, including the New York Police Department’s Operation Nexus program that facilitates reporting of suspicious business encounters.

It is also considering the establishment of a national accreditation scheme that could include training and formalizing policies such as no cash rentals. Companies also generally require business accounts for customers wanting to rent larger trucks, said Poston.

Elsewhere in Europe, Italy has implemented a real-time notification scheme with rental operators and a similar one is being developed in Belgium. Sweden is looking to introduce geofence technology that could connect with a vehicle’s on-board computer and limit its speed to a safe level.

The ease of carrying out such attacks, and the difficulties in detecting them are part of the reason for their rise, said Jeremy Littlewood, an assistant professor at Carleton University’s Norman Paterson School of International Affairs.

“It’s easy to replicate if someone gets that into their head,” said Littlewood.

Littlewood also questioned the effectiveness of background checks. He pointed out that Alek Minassian, now charged with 10 counts of first-degree murder for Monday’s attack, was not known to police.

“So far, police authorities are saying this person was not known to us. And so even if we had a database, our individual in this case is not going to show up from the police side.”

Never entirely zero-risk

Even when perpetrators are known it is still difficult to stop an attack, said Littlewood, noting that Martin Couture-Rouleau was reported to be under RCMP surveillance when in 2014 he used a vehicle in Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu, Que., to hit two members of the Canadian Armed Forces, leaving one dead.

Prevention has instead focused on more cement barriers, and heavy trucks at intersections for major events, but there’s no way to fully prevent this sort of attack entirely, said Littlewood.

“We have to recognize the limits of what can be done here, and the reality is we have to accept there are going to be some risks, and we can never entirely make ourselves into a zero-risk world.”

Also On HuffPost:

North Korea warns it will not give up nuclear weapons until US removes ‘threat’

North Korea has vowed not to unilaterally give up its nuclear weapons unless the US reciprocates by removing its own nuclear threat to Pyongyang, in a blunt statement that casts fresh doubt on whether the current impasse in disarmament talks can be resolved. 

The lengthy rebuke of Washington’s “hostile” policy towards the reclusive regime was delivered by the state-run Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) on Thursday. 

It accused the US of “high-handed practices and pressure” and offered one of the clearest explanations to date of how North Korea views the denuclearisation process. 

At an unprecedented summit in Singapore in June, Kim Jong-un and Donald Trump, the US president, reached an agreement in vague terms to “work towards the complete denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula.”

Talks have since stalled as the two sides have failed to agree on the definition of denuclearisation or on how to move forward. 

“When we refer to the Korean Peninsula, they include both the area of the DPRK [North Korea] and the area of South Korea where aggression troops, including the nuclear weapons of the US, are deployed,” the KCNA commentary clarified. 

“When we refer to the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula, it, therefore, means removing all elements of nuclear threats from the areas of both the north and the south of Korea and also from surrounding areas from where the Korean Peninsula is targeted,” it said.

American nuclear weapons were deployed in South Korea from 1958 to 1991 but now Washington supports Japan and South Korea using bombers and submarines based elsewhere. It also maintains 28,500 American troops in South, which could be a potential sticking point in disarmament negotiations. 

The regime’s statement denounced Washington’s policy since the Singapore summit as “misguided”, saying that it was “aghast” at Mike Pompeo, the US secretary of state’s assertion that Pyongyang had “committed itself to the complete, verifiable and irreversible denuclearisation of North Korea.”

It added: “The US must have a clear understanding of the phrase, denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula, and study geology in particular, before it is too late.”

The latest missive from Pyongyang jars with the more optimistic soundings from Seoul in recent months about Kim’s willingness to cooperate. 

However, it also validates warnings from North Korea analysts and experts, who have consistently argued that Kim Jong-un will not voluntarily relinquish his nuclear arsenal, which he views as both a security guarantee and as giving him a stronger hand in diplomatic negotiations. 

“It has always said this. Some people wanted to delude themselves into believing otherwise. But North Korea is nothing if not consistent,” tweeted Vipin Narang, an associate professor of political science at MIT. 

Writing in NK News, Andrei Lankov, a professor at Kookmin university in Seoul, described the KCNA dispatch as simply “an honest admission of Pyongyang’s real intentions.”

“This statement might have come as a shock to the few remaining nuclear optimists…However, a more unbiased observer should not be surprised at all,” he wrote. 

“North Korea has never had the slightest intention to surrender their nuclear weapons. They saw what happened in Iraq and, more importantly, in Libya, and have long believed that without nuclear weapons they will become vulnerable to both a foreign invasion and a local revolution.” 

Saskatchewan Wants Court Of Appeal To Rule If Trudeau Can Force Carbon Tax On Province

REGINA — The Saskatchewan government is asking the province’s Appeal Court to rule on whether the federal government can impose a carbon tax.

Saskatchewan wants to know whether Ottawa’s plan to bring in a carbon price for provinces that don’t have one violates the Constitution.

Premier Scott Moe’s government has consistently fought against the carbon tax, arguing the province’s own climate-change plans are sufficient to reduce emissions.

“Our constitutional challenge asserts that the provincial government, not the federal government, has the constitutional authority to set our policy in this area,” Moe said at a news conference announcing the challenge Wednesday.

“Provinces are not subsidiaries of the federal government and in Saskatchewan we have a plan. Our plan reduces emissions without a carbon tax.”

The federal climate plan calls for the taxing of greenhouse gas emissions starting at $10 per tonne this year, rising $10 a year to $50 a tonne in 2022.

Saskatchewan is the lone holdout to Ottawa’s demand that those levels be met either through a tax or a cap-and-trade system.

Justice Minister Don Morgan says the government’s constitutional lawyers believe Ottawa’s plan can be successfully challenged because it imposes a tax at different rates depending on how each province responds to the demands.

“We recognize the federal government’s right to levy a tax,” Morgan said. “If there was a total uniform rate, such as GST, it would be a different argument, but that is not the way this is structured.”

Saskatchewan’s climate plan includes performance standards for large emitters, better building codes and a freight delivery strategy, but not a broad-based price on carbon.

The province said it wants a ruling by the end of the year.

The federal climate plan calls for the taxing of greenhouse gas emissions starting at $10 per tonne this year, rising $10 a year to $50 a tonne in 2022.

Saskatchewan is the lone holdout to Ottawa’s demand that those levels be met either through a tax or a cap-and-trade system.

Justice Minister Don Morgan says the government’s constitutional lawyers believe Ottawa’s plan can be successfully challenged because it imposes a tax at different rates depending on how each province responds to the demands.

“We recognize the federal government’s right to levy a tax,” Morgan said. “If there was a total uniform rate, such as GST, it would be a different argument, but that is not the way this is structured.”

Saskatchewan’s climate plan includes performance standards for large emitters, better building codes and a freight delivery strategy, but not a broad-based price on carbon.

The province said it wants a ruling by the end of the year.

Also On HuffPost: